 |
|
 |
|
Next: Stock Investments and Financial Aid
|
| Author |
Message |
External

Since: Jun 22, 2003 Posts: 116
|
(Msg. 1) Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2003 2:03 am
Post subject: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill Archived from groups: soc>college>admissions (more info?)
|
|
|
Colleges Ease Way For Teachers to Get Advanced Degrees
With Higher Pay Automatic, Many Seek Out Programs With Five Courses in Five
Weeks
By DANIEL GOLDEN
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- At Cambridge College no entrance exam or minimum
grade-point average is required to be admitted into the master's program in
education. Most students complete half the coursework in a five-week summer
program and graduate in about six months. Nearly every grade is an "A." And
completing the program guarantees most students a pay increase in their
teaching jobs.
Located near academic powers Harvard University and the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, Cambridge College has quietly developed a national
reputation of its own among schoolteachers seeking a quick credential and
boost in pay. With the federal government and many states demanding more
advanced degrees of teachers -- and providing financial incentives --
Cambridge is one of many schools that have significantly sped up access to
the master's degree in education through nontraditional schedules and other
accommodations.
Some fear that all the shortcuts are putting too much emphasis on
credentials as an end in themselves -- instead of focusing on what's best
for students. "We ought not automatically reward teachers with a salary
increase for master's degrees," says Jennifer King Rice, an education
professor at the University of Maryland, who recently wrote an analysis of
80 studies on teacher training. "We should reward instead specific,
demonstrated mastery of content and teaching methods."
Cambridge administrators say the urgent social need to train teachers
justifies helping them in scheduling, grading and admissions. "We try to be
as flexible as we can without giving away the store," says Jorge Cardoso,
the 51-year-old director of the summer program, called the National
Institute for Teaching Excellence.
Some research suggests that a teacher's gaining an advanced degree,
particularly in education rather than in a specific subject taught, such as
math or science, has little bearing on student performance. More vital are a
teacher's intelligence, experience and mastery of the subject. The 2001 "No
Child Left Behind" law, which requires that all teachers be "highly
qualified" as a condition of federal aid to public schools in high-poverty
areas, specifies that a graduate degree would be one way to meet that
standard. The law also requires -- as do some states -- that schools show
improvement in test scores or face escalating penalties culminating in
shutdowns or state takeovers.
Twenty states require either a master's or graduate course work for teachers
by the end of their first few years on the job, up from only a few states a
decade ago. Nearly all school districts give a salary bump for the master's
credential. In Detroit, the raise amounts to about $9,800, or 16%, for a
teacher with 10 years of experience. In Philadelphia, it's about $7,000, or
13%, for a teacher with 11 years of experience. Under a 1998 law, the
federal government forgives up to $5,000 in student loans for teachers from
high-poverty schools, including borrowing for graduate work.
Eileen Moran Brown, the college's founder and chancellor, says she doesn't
care if teachers enroll to boost their pay, as long as they improve their
skills. "These are practicing teachers already working in classrooms," says
Ms. Brown, 65. "You can either say, 'To hell with them,' or make them
better."
Incentives have spurred a surge in graduate education among teachers,
especially minorities, who have long lagged behind whites in advanced
degrees. The total of all master's degrees awarded in the U.S. rose 15% from
1996 to 2001. But those conferred in education increased 21% overall and by
42% among blacks and 55% among Hispanics.
The growth is taking place mainly in online and satellite, or off-campus,
programs tailored to teachers who lack time and entry requirements for
traditional programs. Enrollment in the online master's program in education
offered by the for-profit University of Phoenix, a unit of consumer-services
company Apollo Group Inc., soared to 4,800 at the end of May from 2,100 a
year earlier.
Lesley College, in Cambridge, Mass., says an estimated 8,547 students will
take its satellite graduate courses in education offered in 20 states this
year, more than double the 4,074 in 2000. Lesley has recently stepped up
recruiting in Georgia and South Carolina, Cambridge's biggest feeder states.
Both Lesley and the University of Phoenix say their programs are as
academically demanding as traditional offerings.
Unlike most traditional programs, none of these schools require entrance
exams such as the Graduate Record Examinations. In a Cambridge College
admissions survey, 42% of graduate students in education said the absence of
tests was one of the three main reasons they chose the school, behind
"flexible schedule" and "adult learning/teaching model."
Founded in 1971, the private, nonprofit college also offers degrees in
psychology, management and other fields. It had 5,000 students and revenue
of $34 million in the year ended June 30. President Mahesh Sharma likens
Cambridge to public colleges that have long beckoned to minorities and
immigrants with open access and low tuition.
Cambridge charges about $10,000 for the master's program in education, half
the cost of most private programs. In the 2001-02 period, the college
awarded 1,397 master's degrees in education, more than all but six schools
in the U.S.
James Baker, who directs a center in Irwinton, Ga., for students considered
in danger of dropping out, is one of five schoolteachers and administrators
in his extended family with Cambridge College graduate degrees in education.
Mr. Baker, 52, estimates that the pay increases from these credentials mean
"an additional half-million dollars coming into this family over the next
decade." He adds: "We have found a user-friendly program to address our
needs in an expedited manner without entrance barriers."
Mr. Baker's niece, Darlene Harrington, an elementary-school teacher in
Decatur, Ga., heard about Cambridge at a family reunion this past spring.
Weeks later, she flew to Massachusetts, handed in her application and began
summer classes the same day. She expects to become the sixth family member
with a Cambridge College degree.
Ms. Harrington, 44, says she has learned valuable lessons about adapting her
teaching to children with a variety of learning styles. "They talked a lot
about teachers coming out of the mode of the traditional classroom and into
the new millennium," she says. "To me, it was an eye-opener."
Cambridge has long enjoyed the support of the Rockefeller family, which has
donated several million dollars to the college. Peggy Dulany, daughter of
financier and banker David Rockefeller, was the college's first chairman of
the board and is currently a trustee.
Asked whether she thought the education-master's program was as challenging
as it should be, Ms. Dulany noted that she hasn't visited courses for
several years because she lives in Montana. However, she said, trustees and
the college's academic leadership want to address any concerns about quality
in the master's program.
The New England Association of Schools and Colleges, which accredits
Cambridge College, cited "quality control of academic achievement" in 1996
as an "issue of overriding concern which is central to the academic
credibility of the college." Two years later, an evaluation team found that
the issue continued to "challenge" the college although it had begun to
establish "effective methods" of assessing student learning. A full review
is scheduled for 2005.
Linda Darling-Hammond, a professor of education at Stanford University, says
she has "never seen a master's degree program organized in that short amount
of time." She also said that compressing the requisite classroom hours for
an entire course into a one-week period is a "perversion of the way" credit
hours "are usually counted."
Ms. Brown, the founder, says Cambridge "is at least comparable or in many
cases superior to what a teacher who decided to go the route of piecing
together courses from their local college would get. The coherence of the
program makes up for less study time." Asked whether the graduates deserve
the salary incentive, she says, "These people are underpaid to begin with.
Think of the pathetic amount of funding that goes into giving teachers a
salary increase, as opposed to what Halliburton is getting" in Iraq.
Cambridge originated as the Institute of Open Education within a Catholic
college for women in Newton, Mass. Teachers weren't graded and received
individualized attention, such as being videotaped in their classrooms and
having the faculty provide critiques.
Such practices lapsed with Cambridge's expansion. Grades were introduced
five years ago at the request of students, Mr. Cardoso says, because school
districts required them before granting pay increases. But, he adds, the
college remains opposed to grades as a "sorting mechanism in our society.
Our philosophy is, 'I want to give you an 'A.' "
If a teacher fails or withdraws from a course, that isn't recorded on the
transcript submitted to his or her school district under what Mr. Cardoso
calls "success-based transcripting."
After becoming independent in 1981, Cambridge predominantly served
Boston-area teachers for a decade. Then it made two key changes that
transformed its summer program into a magnet for teachers nationwide. It
leased dormitory space, and sped up degree-completion time with a liberal
policy on transferring credits from other schools.
The revamped program began in 1991 with 27 teachers and grew steadily. This
past summer the National Institute of Teaching Excellence attracted 993
teachers and administrators pursuing master's degrees or a higher credential
often required for principalship -- the certificate of advanced graduate
study.
Three-fourths receive federal student loans, and 565, or 57%, are black,
mostly from the South. The program draws so many Georgia teachers that it
holds a graduation ceremony every February in Savannah.
Cambridge built the summer program by targeting states and districts that
have big pay incentives for master's degrees and low proportions of teachers
with the credential. The college began recruiting students in Puerto Rico in
1999, the year the island commonwealth raised its pay increase for a
master's degree to $375 a month from $25 a month. Cambridge now plans a
campus in San Juan.
Last year, Mr. Sharma says, Cambridge identified at least six fertile
metropolitan areas: Minneapolis; St. Louis; Cleveland; Cincinnati; and
Atlanta, Savannah and Augusta, Ga.
Candidates for an education master's must fulfill 32 credits -- comparable
to traditional programs. They can get credit for four courses, or 12
credits, completed at other schools. Candidates take one course a week in
the five-week summer program, counting for 15 more credits. The final five
credits come from a seminar where they learn to carry out an independent
project, and from the project itself. Most students complete requirements in
about six months, less than half the standard time.
In the summer program, each class meets for 32 hours -- eight hours a day,
four days a week -- a similar amount of classroom time to traditional
courses meeting two hours a week for a semester. But Cambridge's homework
demands of eight to 12 hours per course violate a longstanding rule of thumb
of at least two hours of homework for each hour of class -- or at least 60
hours per course at many schools.
Cambridge also adapts its curriculum to state standards. It initiated a
summer course in 2001 for masters students called "Spanish for School
Personnel," to help New York teachers fulfill a state requirement that they
take two semesters of a foreign language. Although the 32-hour course counts
as a full semester, instructor James Nocito says that "nobody's going to
become fluent" in a week.
A high-school Spanish teacher, Mr. Nocito says the main aim of the class is
for teachers to learn 20 phrases for emergencies with Hispanic parents or
students. The list, originally designed for police training sessions he
conducted, includes such expressions as "Do you speak English?" "Calm down,"
and "Do exactly what I say" (Haz exactamente lo que yo digo). Mr. Nocito
says the course, which also includes role playing for school events such as
open houses, is so popular that native Spanish speakers sometimes take it
for credit toward their master's degrees, too. He says they like to study
his teaching methods.
Celeste Crook, a 30-year-old kindergarten teacher in Atlanta attended the
summer program this year and took Mr. Nocito's course. "I'm here for the
money," Ms. Crook said. "But being here has renewed my love of teaching."
This summer, in a course titled "Selection, Development and Supervision,"
instructor James Jenkins didn't use a textbook because the one he wanted was
out of print. Students had to write a two-page paper and give an hourlong
group presentation. Mr. Jenkins, a retired former school superintendent in
Oregon who has taught master's classes at Cambridge for nine summers, had
his class demonstrate ways of praising schoolchildren, including the "silent
cheer," "clam clap," "lobster cheer," "rainbow cheer," "butterfly clap," and
"shake your tail feathers." He doesn't give long writing assignments, he
says, because courses are too short. "Academic rigor is one of those things
you give up in this program," he says.
In a course titled "Effective Schools," where degree candidates compared
methods of handling student tardiness and other problems, the class didn't
have time to read an entire textbook. So instructor Hulon Johnson, an
elementary-school principal in Chicago, divided it into groups. Each group
read a few chapters of the text and reported on them to the rest of the
class. Mr. Johnson said the system works for adult learners because they
"get more out of it. You remember 90% of what you teach."
The independent learning projects that complete the program are guided by
faculty members in periodic sessions. The projects include preparing a
handbook or a lesson plan or taking a survey on an educational issue. Due
the December after the summer program, they are the school's substitute for
a thesis.
Mr. Baker, of Irwinton, says he interviewed 100 students and consulted
fellow teachers and administrators for his 92-page project, which involved
designing a model for a character-education program in a rural Georgia high
school. Robert Montrose, a Cleveland health teacher and basketball coach,
surveyed 10 students -- five athletes and five nonathletes -- for his
project exploring the lack of participation on sports teams at his middle
school. Mr. Montrose says his project "would have worked better" with more
students. But Cambridge, he says, "wanted a quick, simple paper."
Copyright 2003 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Sep 28, 2003 Posts: 33
|
(Msg. 2) Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2003 8:32 pm
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
SICK! SICK! SICK!
Those teachers who sought out these degrees ought to be bannished from
teaching for amorality.
"Abe Kohen" <akohen.TakeThisOut@xenon.stanford.edu> wrote in message news:<bkod67$41njt$1@ID-102750.news.uni-berlin.de>...
> Colleges Ease Way For Teachers to Get Advanced Degrees
>
> With Higher Pay Automatic, Many Seek Out Programs With Five Courses in Five
> Weeks
> By DANIEL GOLDEN
> Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
>
>
> CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- At Cambridge College no entrance exam or minimum
> grade-point average is required to be admitted into the master's program in
> education. Most students complete half the coursework in a five-week summer
> program and graduate in about six months. Nearly every grade is an "A." And
> completing the program guarantees most students a pay increase in their
> teaching jobs.
>
> Located near academic powers Harvard University and the Massachusetts
> Institute of Technology, Cambridge College has quietly developed a national
> reputation of its own among schoolteachers seeking a quick credential and
> boost in pay. With the federal government and many states demanding more
> advanced degrees of teachers -- and providing financial incentives --
> Cambridge is one of many schools that have significantly sped up access to
> the master's degree in education through nontraditional schedules and other
> accommodations.
>
> Some fear that all the shortcuts are putting too much emphasis on
> credentials as an end in themselves -- instead of focusing on what's best
> for students. "We ought not automatically reward teachers with a salary
> increase for master's degrees," says Jennifer King Rice, an education
> professor at the University of Maryland, who recently wrote an analysis of
> 80 studies on teacher training. "We should reward instead specific,
> demonstrated mastery of content and teaching methods."
>
> Cambridge administrators say the urgent social need to train teachers
> justifies helping them in scheduling, grading and admissions. "We try to be
> as flexible as we can without giving away the store," says Jorge Cardoso,
> the 51-year-old director of the summer program, called the National
> Institute for Teaching Excellence.
>
> Some research suggests that a teacher's gaining an advanced degree,
> particularly in education rather than in a specific subject taught, such as
> math or science, has little bearing on student performance. More vital are a
> teacher's intelligence, experience and mastery of the subject. The 2001 "No
> Child Left Behind" law, which requires that all teachers be "highly
> qualified" as a condition of federal aid to public schools in high-poverty
> areas, specifies that a graduate degree would be one way to meet that
> standard. The law also requires -- as do some states -- that schools show
> improvement in test scores or face escalating penalties culminating in
> shutdowns or state takeovers.
>
> Twenty states require either a master's or graduate course work for teachers
> by the end of their first few years on the job, up from only a few states a
> decade ago. Nearly all school districts give a salary bump for the master's
> credential. In Detroit, the raise amounts to about $9,800, or 16%, for a
> teacher with 10 years of experience. In Philadelphia, it's about $7,000, or
> 13%, for a teacher with 11 years of experience. Under a 1998 law, the
> federal government forgives up to $5,000 in student loans for teachers from
> high-poverty schools, including borrowing for graduate work.
>
> Eileen Moran Brown, the college's founder and chancellor, says she doesn't
> care if teachers enroll to boost their pay, as long as they improve their
> skills. "These are practicing teachers already working in classrooms," says
> Ms. Brown, 65. "You can either say, 'To hell with them,' or make them
> better."
>
> Incentives have spurred a surge in graduate education among teachers,
> especially minorities, who have long lagged behind whites in advanced
> degrees. The total of all master's degrees awarded in the U.S. rose 15% from
> 1996 to 2001. But those conferred in education increased 21% overall and by
> 42% among blacks and 55% among Hispanics.
>
> The growth is taking place mainly in online and satellite, or off-campus,
> programs tailored to teachers who lack time and entry requirements for
> traditional programs. Enrollment in the online master's program in education
> offered by the for-profit University of Phoenix, a unit of consumer-services
> company Apollo Group Inc., soared to 4,800 at the end of May from 2,100 a
> year earlier.
>
> Lesley College, in Cambridge, Mass., says an estimated 8,547 students will
> take its satellite graduate courses in education offered in 20 states this
> year, more than double the 4,074 in 2000. Lesley has recently stepped up
> recruiting in Georgia and South Carolina, Cambridge's biggest feeder states.
> Both Lesley and the University of Phoenix say their programs are as
> academically demanding as traditional offerings.
>
> Unlike most traditional programs, none of these schools require entrance
> exams such as the Graduate Record Examinations. In a Cambridge College
> admissions survey, 42% of graduate students in education said the absence of
> tests was one of the three main reasons they chose the school, behind
> "flexible schedule" and "adult learning/teaching model."
>
> Founded in 1971, the private, nonprofit college also offers degrees in
> psychology, management and other fields. It had 5,000 students and revenue
> of $34 million in the year ended June 30. President Mahesh Sharma likens
> Cambridge to public colleges that have long beckoned to minorities and
> immigrants with open access and low tuition.
>
> Cambridge charges about $10,000 for the master's program in education, half
> the cost of most private programs. In the 2001-02 period, the college
> awarded 1,397 master's degrees in education, more than all but six schools
> in the U.S.
>
> James Baker, who directs a center in Irwinton, Ga., for students considered
> in danger of dropping out, is one of five schoolteachers and administrators
> in his extended family with Cambridge College graduate degrees in education.
> Mr. Baker, 52, estimates that the pay increases from these credentials mean
> "an additional half-million dollars coming into this family over the next
> decade." He adds: "We have found a user-friendly program to address our
> needs in an expedited manner without entrance barriers."
>
> Mr. Baker's niece, Darlene Harrington, an elementary-school teacher in
> Decatur, Ga., heard about Cambridge at a family reunion this past spring.
> Weeks later, she flew to Massachusetts, handed in her application and began
> summer classes the same day. She expects to become the sixth family member
> with a Cambridge College degree.
>
> Ms. Harrington, 44, says she has learned valuable lessons about adapting her
> teaching to children with a variety of learning styles. "They talked a lot
> about teachers coming out of the mode of the traditional classroom and into
> the new millennium," she says. "To me, it was an eye-opener."
>
> Cambridge has long enjoyed the support of the Rockefeller family, which has
> donated several million dollars to the college. Peggy Dulany, daughter of
> financier and banker David Rockefeller, was the college's first chairman of
> the board and is currently a trustee.
>
> Asked whether she thought the education-master's program was as challenging
> as it should be, Ms. Dulany noted that she hasn't visited courses for
> several years because she lives in Montana. However, she said, trustees and
> the college's academic leadership want to address any concerns about quality
> in the master's program.
>
> The New England Association of Schools and Colleges, which accredits
> Cambridge College, cited "quality control of academic achievement" in 1996
> as an "issue of overriding concern which is central to the academic
> credibility of the college." Two years later, an evaluation team found that
> the issue continued to "challenge" the college although it had begun to
> establish "effective methods" of assessing student learning. A full review
> is scheduled for 2005.
>
> Linda Darling-Hammond, a professor of education at Stanford University, says
> she has "never seen a master's degree program organized in that short amount
> of time." She also said that compressing the requisite classroom hours for
> an entire course into a one-week period is a "perversion of the way" credit
> hours "are usually counted."
>
> Ms. Brown, the founder, says Cambridge "is at least comparable or in many
> cases superior to what a teacher who decided to go the route of piecing
> together courses from their local college would get. The coherence of the
> program makes up for less study time." Asked whether the graduates deserve
> the salary incentive, she says, "These people are underpaid to begin with.
> Think of the pathetic amount of funding that goes into giving teachers a
> salary increase, as opposed to what Halliburton is getting" in Iraq.
>
> Cambridge originated as the Institute of Open Education within a Catholic
> college for women in Newton, Mass. Teachers weren't graded and received
> individualized attention, such as being videotaped in their classrooms and
> having the faculty provide critiques.
>
> Such practices lapsed with Cambridge's expansion. Grades were introduced
> five years ago at the request of students, Mr. Cardoso says, because school
> districts required them before granting pay increases. But, he adds, the
> college remains opposed to grades as a "sorting mechanism in our society.
> Our philosophy is, 'I want to give you an 'A.' "
>
> If a teacher fails or withdraws from a course, that isn't recorded on the
> transcript submitted to his or her school district under what Mr. Cardoso
> calls "success-based transcripting."
>
> After becoming independent in 1981, Cambridge predominantly served
> Boston-area teachers for a decade. Then it made two key changes that
> transformed its summer program into a magnet for teachers nationwide. It
> leased dormitory space, and sped up degree-completion time with a liberal
> policy on transferring credits from other schools.
>
> The revamped program began in 1991 with 27 teachers and grew steadily. This
> past summer the National Institute of Teaching Excellence attracted 993
> teachers and administrators pursuing master's degrees or a higher credential
> often required for principalship -- the certificate of advanced graduate
> study.
>
> Three-fourths receive federal student loans, and 565, or 57%, are black,
> mostly from the South. The program draws so many Georgia teachers that it
> holds a graduation ceremony every February in Savannah.
>
> Cambridge built the summer program by targeting states and districts that
> have big pay incentives for master's degrees and low proportions of teachers
> with the credential. The college began recruiting students in Puerto Rico in
> 1999, the year the island commonwealth raised its pay increase for a
> master's degree to $375 a month from $25 a month. Cambridge now plans a
> campus in San Juan.
>
> Last year, Mr. Sharma says, Cambridge identified at least six fertile
> metropolitan areas: Minneapolis; St. Louis; Cleveland; Cincinnati; and
> Atlanta, Savannah and Augusta, Ga.
>
> Candidates for an education master's must fulfill 32 credits -- comparable
> to traditional programs. They can get credit for four courses, or 12
> credits, completed at other schools. Candidates take one course a week in
> the five-week summer program, counting for 15 more credits. The final five
> credits come from a seminar where they learn to carry out an independent
> project, and from the project itself. Most students complete requirements in
> about six months, less than half the standard time.
>
> In the summer program, each class meets for 32 hours -- eight hours a day,
> four days a week -- a similar amount of classroom time to traditional
> courses meeting two hours a week for a semester. But Cambridge's homework
> demands of eight to 12 hours per course violate a longstanding rule of thumb
> of at least two hours of homework for each hour of class -- or at least 60
> hours per course at many schools.
>
> Cambridge also adapts its curriculum to state standards. It initiated a
> summer course in 2001 for masters students called "Spanish for School
> Personnel," to help New York teachers fulfill a state requirement that they
> take two semesters of a foreign language. Although the 32-hour course counts
> as a full semester, instructor James Nocito says that "nobody's going to
> become fluent" in a week.
>
> A high-school Spanish teacher, Mr. Nocito says the main aim of the class is
> for teachers to learn 20 phrases for emergencies with Hispanic parents or
> students. The list, originally designed for police training sessions he
> conducted, includes such expressions as "Do you speak English?" "Calm down,"
> and "Do exactly what I say" (Haz exactamente lo que yo digo). Mr. Nocito
> says the course, which also includes role playing for school events such as
> open houses, is so popular that native Spanish speakers sometimes take it
> for credit toward their master's degrees, too. He says they like to study
> his teaching methods.
>
> Celeste Crook, a 30-year-old kindergarten teacher in Atlanta attended the
> summer program this year and took Mr. Nocito's course. "I'm here for the
> money," Ms. Crook said. "But being here has renewed my love of teaching."
>
> This summer, in a course titled "Selection, Development and Supervision,"
> instructor James Jenkins didn't use a textbook because the one he wanted was
> out of print. Students had to write a two-page paper and give an hourlong
> group presentation. Mr. Jenkins, a retired former school superintendent in
> Oregon who has taught master's classes at Cambridge for nine summers, had
> his class demonstrate ways of praising schoolchildren, including the "silent
> cheer," "clam clap," "lobster cheer," "rainbow cheer," "butterfly clap," and
> "shake your tail feathers." He doesn't give long writing assignments, he
> says, because courses are too short. "Academic rigor is one of those things
> you give up in this program," he says.
>
> In a course titled "Effective Schools," where degree candidates compared
> methods of handling student tardiness and other problems, the class didn't
> have time to read an entire textbook. So instructor Hulon Johnson, an
> elementary-school principal in Chicago, divided it into groups. Each group
> read a few chapters of the text and reported on them to the rest of the
> class. Mr. Johnson said the system works for adult learners because they
> "get more out of it. You remember 90% of what you teach."
>
> The independent learning projects that complete the program are guided by
> faculty members in periodic sessions. The projects include preparing a
> handbook or a lesson plan or taking a survey on an educational issue. Due
> the December after the summer program, they are the school's substitute for
> a thesis.
>
> Mr. Baker, of Irwinton, says he interviewed 100 students and consulted
> fellow teachers and administrators for his 92-page project, which involved
> designing a model for a character-education program in a rural Georgia high
> school. Robert Montrose, a Cleveland health teacher and basketball coach,
> surveyed 10 students -- five athletes and five nonathletes -- for his
> project exploring the lack of participation on sports teams at his middle
> school. Mr. Montrose says his project "would have worked better" with more
> students. But Cambridge, he says, "wanted a quick, simple paper."
>
> Copyright 2003 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Jun 22, 2003 Posts: 116
|
(Msg. 3) Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2003 11:51 pm
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
The education establishment is behind the ridiculous requirements for
teaching certificates/ licenses.
Most of what is taught in Schools of Education (schools which produce
teachers) is unadulterated garbage.
A teacher, especially at the high school level needs content knowledge,
motivation and the ability to motivate others. Period. (Full stop - in
British English.)
Cambridge College is one of the most egregious of those taking money from
underpaid teachers. Just a degree mill. They don't even pretend to wrap the
manure in toilet paper.
Abe
"octo" <octogenarian.TakeThisOut@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:a0eff15b.0309231632.2f9ba106@posting.google.com...
> SICK! SICK! SICK!
>
> Those teachers who sought out these degrees ought to be bannished from
> teaching for amorality.
>
>
> "Abe Kohen" <akohen.TakeThisOut@xenon.stanford.edu> wrote in message
news:<bkod67$41njt$1@ID-102750.news.uni-berlin.de>...
> > Colleges Ease Way For Teachers to Get Advanced Degrees
> >
> > With Higher Pay Automatic, Many Seek Out Programs With Five Courses in
Five
> > Weeks
> > By DANIEL GOLDEN
> > Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
> >
> >
> > CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- At Cambridge College no entrance exam or minimum
> > grade-point average is required to be admitted into the master's program
in
> > education. Most students complete half the coursework in a five-week
summer
> > program and graduate in about six months. Nearly every grade is an "A."
And
> > completing the program guarantees most students a pay increase in their
> > teaching jobs.
> >
> > Located near academic powers Harvard University and the Massachusetts
> > Institute of Technology, Cambridge College has quietly developed a
national
> > reputation of its own among schoolteachers seeking a quick credential
and
> > boost in pay. With the federal government and many states demanding more
> > advanced degrees of teachers -- and providing financial incentives --
> > Cambridge is one of many schools that have significantly sped up access
to
> > the master's degree in education through nontraditional schedules and
other
> > accommodations.
> >
> > Some fear that all the shortcuts are putting too much emphasis on
> > credentials as an end in themselves -- instead of focusing on what's
best
> > for students. "We ought not automatically reward teachers with a salary
> > increase for master's degrees," says Jennifer King Rice, an education
> > professor at the University of Maryland, who recently wrote an analysis
of
> > 80 studies on teacher training. "We should reward instead specific,
> > demonstrated mastery of content and teaching methods."
> >
> > Cambridge administrators say the urgent social need to train teachers
> > justifies helping them in scheduling, grading and admissions. "We try to
be
> > as flexible as we can without giving away the store," says Jorge
Cardoso,
> > the 51-year-old director of the summer program, called the National
> > Institute for Teaching Excellence.
> >
> > Some research suggests that a teacher's gaining an advanced degree,
> > particularly in education rather than in a specific subject taught, such
as
> > math or science, has little bearing on student performance. More vital
are a
> > teacher's intelligence, experience and mastery of the subject. The 2001
"No
> > Child Left Behind" law, which requires that all teachers be "highly
> > qualified" as a condition of federal aid to public schools in
high-poverty
> > areas, specifies that a graduate degree would be one way to meet that
> > standard. The law also requires -- as do some states -- that schools
show
> > improvement in test scores or face escalating penalties culminating in
> > shutdowns or state takeovers.
> >
> > Twenty states require either a master's or graduate course work for
teachers
> > by the end of their first few years on the job, up from only a few
states a
> > decade ago. Nearly all school districts give a salary bump for the
master's
> > credential. In Detroit, the raise amounts to about $9,800, or 16%, for a
> > teacher with 10 years of experience. In Philadelphia, it's about $7,000,
or
> > 13%, for a teacher with 11 years of experience. Under a 1998 law, the
> > federal government forgives up to $5,000 in student loans for teachers
from
> > high-poverty schools, including borrowing for graduate work.
> >
> > Eileen Moran Brown, the college's founder and chancellor, says she
doesn't
> > care if teachers enroll to boost their pay, as long as they improve
their
> > skills. "These are practicing teachers already working in classrooms,"
says
> > Ms. Brown, 65. "You can either say, 'To hell with them,' or make them
> > better."
> >
> > Incentives have spurred a surge in graduate education among teachers,
> > especially minorities, who have long lagged behind whites in advanced
> > degrees. The total of all master's degrees awarded in the U.S. rose 15%
from
> > 1996 to 2001. But those conferred in education increased 21% overall and
by
> > 42% among blacks and 55% among Hispanics.
> >
> > The growth is taking place mainly in online and satellite, or
off-campus,
> > programs tailored to teachers who lack time and entry requirements for
> > traditional programs. Enrollment in the online master's program in
education
> > offered by the for-profit University of Phoenix, a unit of
consumer-services
> > company Apollo Group Inc., soared to 4,800 at the end of May from 2,100
a
> > year earlier.
> >
> > Lesley College, in Cambridge, Mass., says an estimated 8,547 students
will
> > take its satellite graduate courses in education offered in 20 states
this
> > year, more than double the 4,074 in 2000. Lesley has recently stepped up
> > recruiting in Georgia and South Carolina, Cambridge's biggest feeder
states.
> > Both Lesley and the University of Phoenix say their programs are as
> > academically demanding as traditional offerings.
> >
> > Unlike most traditional programs, none of these schools require entrance
> > exams such as the Graduate Record Examinations. In a Cambridge College
> > admissions survey, 42% of graduate students in education said the
absence of
> > tests was one of the three main reasons they chose the school, behind
> > "flexible schedule" and "adult learning/teaching model."
> >
> > Founded in 1971, the private, nonprofit college also offers degrees in
> > psychology, management and other fields. It had 5,000 students and
revenue
> > of $34 million in the year ended June 30. President Mahesh Sharma likens
> > Cambridge to public colleges that have long beckoned to minorities and
> > immigrants with open access and low tuition.
> >
> > Cambridge charges about $10,000 for the master's program in education,
half
> > the cost of most private programs. In the 2001-02 period, the college
> > awarded 1,397 master's degrees in education, more than all but six
schools
> > in the U.S.
> >
> > James Baker, who directs a center in Irwinton, Ga., for students
considered
> > in danger of dropping out, is one of five schoolteachers and
administrators
> > in his extended family with Cambridge College graduate degrees in
education.
> > Mr. Baker, 52, estimates that the pay increases from these credentials
mean
> > "an additional half-million dollars coming into this family over the
next
> > decade." He adds: "We have found a user-friendly program to address our
> > needs in an expedited manner without entrance barriers."
> >
> > Mr. Baker's niece, Darlene Harrington, an elementary-school teacher in
> > Decatur, Ga., heard about Cambridge at a family reunion this past
spring.
> > Weeks later, she flew to Massachusetts, handed in her application and
began
> > summer classes the same day. She expects to become the sixth family
member
> > with a Cambridge College degree.
> >
> > Ms. Harrington, 44, says she has learned valuable lessons about adapting
her
> > teaching to children with a variety of learning styles. "They talked a
lot
> > about teachers coming out of the mode of the traditional classroom and
into
> > the new millennium," she says. "To me, it was an eye-opener."
> >
> > Cambridge has long enjoyed the support of the Rockefeller family, which
has
> > donated several million dollars to the college. Peggy Dulany, daughter
of
> > financier and banker David Rockefeller, was the college's first chairman
of
> > the board and is currently a trustee.
> >
> > Asked whether she thought the education-master's program was as
challenging
> > as it should be, Ms. Dulany noted that she hasn't visited courses for
> > several years because she lives in Montana. However, she said, trustees
and
> > the college's academic leadership want to address any concerns about
quality
> > in the master's program.
> >
> > The New England Association of Schools and Colleges, which accredits
> > Cambridge College, cited "quality control of academic achievement" in
1996
> > as an "issue of overriding concern which is central to the academic
> > credibility of the college." Two years later, an evaluation team found
that
> > the issue continued to "challenge" the college although it had begun to
> > establish "effective methods" of assessing student learning. A full
review
> > is scheduled for 2005.
> >
> > Linda Darling-Hammond, a professor of education at Stanford University,
says
> > she has "never seen a master's degree program organized in that short
amount
> > of time." She also said that compressing the requisite classroom hours
for
> > an entire course into a one-week period is a "perversion of the way"
credit
> > hours "are usually counted."
> >
> > Ms. Brown, the founder, says Cambridge "is at least comparable or in
many
> > cases superior to what a teacher who decided to go the route of piecing
> > together courses from their local college would get. The coherence of
the
> > program makes up for less study time." Asked whether the graduates
deserve
> > the salary incentive, she says, "These people are underpaid to begin
with.
> > Think of the pathetic amount of funding that goes into giving teachers a
> > salary increase, as opposed to what Halliburton is getting" in Iraq.
> >
> > Cambridge originated as the Institute of Open Education within a
Catholic
> > college for women in Newton, Mass. Teachers weren't graded and received
> > individualized attention, such as being videotaped in their classrooms
and
> > having the faculty provide critiques.
> >
> > Such practices lapsed with Cambridge's expansion. Grades were introduced
> > five years ago at the request of students, Mr. Cardoso says, because
school
> > districts required them before granting pay increases. But, he adds, the
> > college remains opposed to grades as a "sorting mechanism in our
society.
> > Our philosophy is, 'I want to give you an 'A.' "
> >
> > If a teacher fails or withdraws from a course, that isn't recorded on
the
> > transcript submitted to his or her school district under what Mr.
Cardoso
> > calls "success-based transcripting."
> >
> > After becoming independent in 1981, Cambridge predominantly served
> > Boston-area teachers for a decade. Then it made two key changes that
> > transformed its summer program into a magnet for teachers nationwide. It
> > leased dormitory space, and sped up degree-completion time with a
liberal
> > policy on transferring credits from other schools.
> >
> > The revamped program began in 1991 with 27 teachers and grew steadily.
This
> > past summer the National Institute of Teaching Excellence attracted 993
> > teachers and administrators pursuing master's degrees or a higher
credential
> > often required for principalship -- the certificate of advanced graduate
> > study.
> >
> > Three-fourths receive federal student loans, and 565, or 57%, are black,
> > mostly from the South. The program draws so many Georgia teachers that
it
> > holds a graduation ceremony every February in Savannah.
> >
> > Cambridge built the summer program by targeting states and districts
that
> > have big pay incentives for master's degrees and low proportions of
teachers
> > with the credential. The college began recruiting students in Puerto
Rico in
> > 1999, the year the island commonwealth raised its pay increase for a
> > master's degree to $375 a month from $25 a month. Cambridge now plans a
> > campus in San Juan.
> >
> > Last year, Mr. Sharma says, Cambridge identified at least six fertile
> > metropolitan areas: Minneapolis; St. Louis; Cleveland; Cincinnati; and
> > Atlanta, Savannah and Augusta, Ga.
> >
> > Candidates for an education master's must fulfill 32 credits --
comparable
> > to traditional programs. They can get credit for four courses, or 12
> > credits, completed at other schools. Candidates take one course a week
in
> > the five-week summer program, counting for 15 more credits. The final
five
> > credits come from a seminar where they learn to carry out an independent
> > project, and from the project itself. Most students complete
requirements in
> > about six months, less than half the standard time.
> >
> > In the summer program, each class meets for 32 hours -- eight hours a
day,
> > four days a week -- a similar amount of classroom time to traditional
> > courses meeting two hours a week for a semester. But Cambridge's
homework
> > demands of eight to 12 hours per course violate a longstanding rule of
thumb
> > of at least two hours of homework for each hour of class -- or at least
60
> > hours per course at many schools.
> >
> > Cambridge also adapts its curriculum to state standards. It initiated a
> > summer course in 2001 for masters students called "Spanish for School
> > Personnel," to help New York teachers fulfill a state requirement that
they
> > take two semesters of a foreign language. Although the 32-hour course
counts
> > as a full semester, instructor James Nocito says that "nobody's going to
> > become fluent" in a week.
> >
> > A high-school Spanish teacher, Mr. Nocito says the main aim of the class
is
> > for teachers to learn 20 phrases for emergencies with Hispanic parents
or
> > students. The list, originally designed for police training sessions he
> > conducted, includes such expressions as "Do you speak English?" "Calm
down,"
> > and "Do exactly what I say" (Haz exactamente lo que yo digo). Mr. Nocito
> > says the course, which also includes role playing for school events such
as
> > open houses, is so popular that native Spanish speakers sometimes take
it
> > for credit toward their master's degrees, too. He says they like to
study
> > his teaching methods.
> >
> > Celeste Crook, a 30-year-old kindergarten teacher in Atlanta attended
the
> > summer program this year and took Mr. Nocito's course. "I'm here for the
> > money," Ms. Crook said. "But being here has renewed my love of
teaching."
> >
> > This summer, in a course titled "Selection, Development and
Supervision,"
> > instructor James Jenkins didn't use a textbook because the one he wanted
was
> > out of print. Students had to write a two-page paper and give an
hourlong
> > group presentation. Mr. Jenkins, a retired former school superintendent
in
> > Oregon who has taught master's classes at Cambridge for nine summers,
had
> > his class demonstrate ways of praising schoolchildren, including the
"silent
> > cheer," "clam clap," "lobster cheer," "rainbow cheer," "butterfly clap,"
and
> > "shake your tail feathers." He doesn't give long writing assignments, he
> > says, because courses are too short. "Academic rigor is one of those
things
> > you give up in this program," he says.
> >
> > In a course titled "Effective Schools," where degree candidates compared
> > methods of handling student tardiness and other problems, the class
didn't
> > have time to read an entire textbook. So instructor Hulon Johnson, an
> > elementary-school principal in Chicago, divided it into groups. Each
group
> > read a few chapters of the text and reported on them to the rest of the
> > class. Mr. Johnson said the system works for adult learners because they
> > "get more out of it. You remember 90% of what you teach."
> >
> > The independent learning projects that complete the program are guided
by
> > faculty members in periodic sessions. The projects include preparing a
> > handbook or a lesson plan or taking a survey on an educational issue.
Due
> > the December after the summer program, they are the school's substitute
for
> > a thesis.
> >
> > Mr. Baker, of Irwinton, says he interviewed 100 students and consulted
> > fellow teachers and administrators for his 92-page project, which
involved
> > designing a model for a character-education program in a rural Georgia
high
> > school. Robert Montrose, a Cleveland health teacher and basketball
coach,
> > surveyed 10 students -- five athletes and five nonathletes -- for his
> > project exploring the lack of participation on sports teams at his
middle
> > school. Mr. Montrose says his project "would have worked better" with
more
> > students. But Cambridge, he says, "wanted a quick, simple paper."
> >
> > Copyright 2003 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Sep 28, 2003 Posts: 26
|
(Msg. 4) Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2003 1:19 am
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
"Abe Kohen" <akohen.RemoveThis@xenon.stanford.edu> wrote in message news:<bl7vq5$9bdl0$1@ID-102750.news.uni-berlin.de>...
> The education establishment is behind the ridiculous requirements for
> teaching certificates/ licenses.
>
> Most of what is taught in Schools of Education (schools which produce
> teachers) is unadulterated garbage.
>
> A teacher, especially at the high school level needs content knowledge,
> motivation and the ability to motivate others. Period. (Full stop - in
> British English.)
I think the content knowledge is easy. Motivation folks might have,
but where do you get the ability to motivate others?
This is like saying the only thing you need to know to do math is to
know the notation, how to make up statements, and then how to prove
statements. Period.
KSG >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Oct 27, 2003 Posts: 20
|
(Msg. 5) Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2003 9:16 am
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
"KSG" <ksg619 DeleteThis @hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:f55f01d6.0309282119.738d4046@posting.google.com...
> I think the content knowledge is easy. Motivation folks might have,
> but where do you get the ability to motivate others?
The ability to motivate others to learn is a gift, not something that can be
taught in college and not something that can be improved with greater
knowledge of content. It is a gift two of my daughters have (and have had
since they were little) and one in which I am severely lacking despite a
great deal of education and knowledge. >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Sep 28, 2003 Posts: 26
|
(Msg. 6) Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2003 2:30 am
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
"Kath" <kathryn.havemann RemoveThis @lexisnexis.com> wrote in message news:<bl90q9$61l$1@mailgate2.lexis-nexis.com>...
> "KSG" <ksg619 RemoveThis @hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:f55f01d6.0309282119.738d4046@posting.google.com...
> > I think the content knowledge is easy. Motivation folks might have,
> > but where do you get the ability to motivate others?
>
> The ability to motivate others to learn is a gift, not something that can be
> taught in college and not something that can be improved with greater
> knowledge of content.
I disagree. Almost everything I know about how to motivate students I
learned from watching others.
KSG >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Mar 17, 2004 Posts: 16
|
(Msg. 7) Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2003 11:11 am
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
> I disagree. Almost everything I know about how to motivate students I
> learned from watching others.
>
> KSG
KSG,
Okay, I'll bite. I want to know. How do you motivate students? There
must be a book on this. If not, you should write it.
Sal >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
External

Since: Sep 28, 2003 Posts: 26
|
(Msg. 8) Posted: Wed Oct 01, 2003 7:04 pm
Post subject: Re: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill [Login to view extended thread Info.] Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)
|
|
|
sunsol.RemoveThis@prodigy.net (Sally) wrote in message news:<2398fe97.0310010711.3d277f4c.RemoveThis@posting.google.com>...
> > I disagree. Almost everything I know about how to motivate students I
> > learned from watching others.
> >
> > KSG
>
>
> KSG,
>
> Okay, I'll bite. I want to know. How do you motivate students? There
> must be a book on this. If not, you should write it.
Well it shouldn't be me that writes it (as there are people that are
better). Here are a couple of things that I've seen that work well
(and a lot of this varies based on the students):
1) Practicality of material. I opened a lecture on physics with a
cellphone with a display that did not work outside. It was partially
a comedy routine, but it got the students into. (it was about
polarizing lenses). One student came in the next meeting with an
interesting list of different uses for polarization.
2) Make learning about discovery. Emphasize the "Aha!".
3) Motive and remotivate. That is motivate in different ways for
different students.
4) Show connections, stepping stones. This is coupled with point #2.
You want students to realize that learning isn't a dead-end, but
rather a means to an "Aha!" moment.
5) Show the current state of the art. I often start a new topic with
what is on the cutting edge of the field. This gives students
motivation to pursue the boundary, because they think it is
interesting.
6) Talk about when you were in their same position. When students can
see that you were once where they are and had similar struggles, they
suddenly realize that they can be where you are.
These are the types of things can be learned. And I think by watching
people skilled at this you can learn quite a bit. Additionally
reading research on what works is useful too. Things from "when does
too much homework demotivate" or "groups of four or more are bad for
math".
There are few reasons why learning/teaching and motivation shouldn't
be treated as a science, except our belief that they are some mystical
devices.
KSG >> Stay informed about: WSJ: Teacher Degree Mill |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |  |
|
You can post new topics in this forum You can reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|